Skip to content

51 Sarah Drive Offered at TBD - Lake Grove, NY 11755

4 Bedrooms

2  Bathrooms

1964 Year Built

0.33 Acres

School District

MLS

Experience Pride of Ownership in Lake Grove Estates!
Fall in love with this charming Colonial home, set on a stunning 1/3-acre landscaped property—much larger than most neighborhood lots, offering privacy, space, and room to grow. Featuring low property taxes with the Basic STAR exemption ($8,906!), you’ll appreciate how affordable it is to enjoy everything this home and community have to offer.
 
Home Highlights:
• 4 spacious bedrooms
 • Recently installed brand new roof
 • Bright living room with fireplace and slider doors to a paved patio for maximum sunlight and seamless indoor-outdoor living
 • Huge, fully fenced backyard with a sparkling in-ground pool (18’ x 36’)—perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or making family memories
 • Formal dining room featuring a beautiful skylight
 • Gas heat for efficiency and comfort
 • One-car garage
 • In-ground sprinklers & Belgium block driveway
 
Live Where Convenience Meets Lifestyle
Lake Grove is truly Long Island’s hidden gem, combining the serenity of a quiet suburban community with amazing accessibility. Enjoy unbeatable proximity to:
 • Smith Haven Mall: Over 130 stores—Costco, Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Primark, and more, plus top restaurants like Cheesecake Factory, P.F. Chang’s, and Texas de Brazil
 • Parks and Recreation: Nearby nature preserves, county parks, and family-friendly activities like the Lake Ronkonkoma Recreation Center, hiking trails, and playgrounds
 • Restaurants & Cafes: A diverse array of both national chains and local favorites, from Italian to international cuisine
 • Long Island Rail Road (LIRR): Fast and simple access to NYC (about 80 minutes by rail!), plus quick trips to MacArthur Airport, St. James vineyards, and the Port Jefferson ferry
 • Excellent schools in several top-rated districts, and a welcoming, friendly community praised for diversity and neighborly spirit
Financial Peace of Mind
 
Lake Grove’s strict budget and efficient local government means tax increases are kept low, while homeowners benefit from a variety of property tax exemptions—including STAR, senior, veteran, and disability programs. These advantages keep your cost of living down while maximizing comfort, security, and convenience.
The combination of a spacious lot with a pool, fantastic tax base, and unbeatable location makes this home a must-see and an incredible value. Discover your next chapter in Lake Grove Estates—schedule a tour today!
 

SPACE TO UNWIND SPACE TO UNWIND INSIDE AND OUT

Floor Plans & Grounds Floor Plans & Grounds Take an immersive look at this home. 

3D Virtual Tour 3D Virtual Tour

Highlighted Features of Lake Grove

Map 51 Sarah Drive, Lake Grove, NY 11755

FOR SHOWINGS CONTACT

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Gregory Berkowitz

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Fatima Smith

Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker